With its signature vibrancy, unmistakable demeanor, and visual grandeur, New York City has been a romantic comedy line for so long that the place has become a cliché. So how does it work Jonah Feingold, the writer / director of “Dating & New York” do you want to make your mark on this sparkling skyline? By creating a postmodern rom-com that wraps unmistakably iconic influences to deliver a disrespectful commentary on the genre and modern romance.
READ MORE: 2021 Tribeca Film Festival Preview: 15 Must-See Movies & More
Jaboukie Young white and Francesca Reale The main roles are played by Milo and Wendy, a young couple who date, haunt each other and then withdraw to become friends with benefits. Could this be the tortuous road to true love? Unfortunately, their respective besties are a neat one Brian Muller and a naughty one Catherine Cohen– don’t think so, because someone will always “trap” and end up heartbroken.
READ MORE: Summer 2021 Preview: Over 50 Movies to Watch
“Dating & New York” plays like “When Harry met Sally“For millennials in their twenties. The classic rom-com thesis that men and women can never really be just friends is upgraded to F * ck Friends and will always lead to heartbreak. And just as the eponymous lovers of the 80s ignored all romantic advice, Milo and Wendy immerse themselves in a relationship of friendship, sex and cuddling – but no romance and no “I love you”. Perhaps alluding to Billy Crystal, Milo is a stand-up comedian. Probably alluding to Meg Ryan’s Sally, Wendy is charming, controlling, and has an intense penchant for turtlenecks. She argues that this plan is fine for perks friends because everything is written in their contract. (Apparently she cannot be seen “Can’t buy me love ” or “To all the boys I loved before!”) Of course, Milo falls in love with the girl who swears she will never love him and suffers when she dates other guys. Fortunately for him, all these men aren’t as much of a threat as a parade of flimsy Fickboi stereotypes: douchey fedora wearers, arrogant app developers, and tearful podcasters questioning their exes about what went wrong.
READ MORE: The 100 Most Anticipated Movies of 2021
Feingold takes advantage of the fame of New York City and leads his lovers (and their buddies) to shimmering subway stations, on the sunlit ferry, to cozy ice cream parlors and glamorous rooftop bars and through a rainy but beautiful Central Park with them joke all the way. When he can’t find a place, this inventive director uses a whimsical watercolor as a succinct exterior. An opening sequence full of these works of art helps paint the expectation of a romanticized version of New York City backed up by an aggressively sugar-sweet score. Strings, piano and choral singing suggest that this will be a fairy tale, while the bold narrator (Jerry Ferrara) uses a snarky phrase with explanations such as “[New York] is the city that never sleeps, but sleeps around. ”
These flourishes collide with a highly saturated color palette that acts like an allusion to Wes Anderson‘s aesthetic with its warm autumn gold and blushing pink tones. However, the settings are decidedly less twee; Towering garbage bags frame a first kiss. Meanwhile, Feingold’s characters are more serious and overtly neurotic, perhaps reflecting the online dating atmosphere where kinks and deal breakers appear in bio blurbs. Speaking of which, in a knowing allusion to the Rom-Com Convention, Milo and Wendy are introduced via a dating app called “Meet Cute”. It’s good to laugh about, but unfortunately it undermines a crucial moment in the establishment of chemistry. Fortunately, Young-White and Reale bounce back with a winning first-date scene in which they definitely share a spark. This romance doesn’t turn out to be hot, however. They are cute, but they don’t click.
Instead, the subplot about the sidekick beasts they fall into
a whirlwind romance (another element of “When Harry Met Sally”) steals focus.
Maybe because Muller and Cohen click, but more like Catherine Cohen
is absolutely fascinating. From her first wry smile and snapping joke
she proves that Carrie Fisher, funny, radiant and – why isn’t this film
all about you?
Shimmering scene thief aside, the problem is fine gold
sews comedic pieces together rather than a flowing narrative. For Milo there is
a look back at a past relationship explosion and a painfully uncomfortable subway
Breakup (with a stellar cameo by a viral comedian Eva Viktor). To the
Wendy, things suddenly turn fantastic, with a bad date turning into one
Walkway therapy session – complete with an upholstered couch and work lamp – and
another becomes a literal press conference to be tormented
what she is looking for. Some of them are imaginative and fun, but they create
a chaotic pace that makes the stumbling romance plot pathetic
Dating & New York’s meta-comment on rom-coms is fascinating at first, from the Meet Cute app to Milo complaining that he is a “manic pixie dream boy”. Feingold, however, never strings a cohesive review or narrative together, making the film feel more like a brainstorming session or work in progress or even a snappy Twitter thread. The story runs out of breath before this chunky clutch even gets to brunch (because there’s a brunch scene, of course). So we wait impatiently for the happy ending. But be warned, Feingold thinks it’s too smart for that. True to the cynicism that fluctuates superficially throughout rom-coms, it delivers one final beat that’s so outrageously out of place that I rewound twice to make sure I didn’t miss anything. It was not me. It was just that bad. [C-]
Follow all of our coverage of the 2021 Tribeca Film Festival here.